Kidon / Metsada (Komemiute)
Reference. Reports what the sources say. States no conclusion of ours.
Edition label: 2026-11
Secondary-source summary. This page summarises published books and memoirs (Whitney Webb, Victor Ostrovsky, Gordon Thomas and Martin Dillon, Ari Ben-Menashe, Israel Shahak). Allegations are attributed to their authors and are not independently established by primary records held in this archive. Not everything on this page is footnoted. Our citation check covers the main text, but not headings, the lists of related entries and sources, or open questions, which may state facts without a footnote. Check the footnoted text or the source before relying on them.
Definition: A unit described by Victor Ostrovsky as responsible for assassinations within Mossad’s special-operations structure.1 The organizational descriptions, execution procedures and rules below summarize historical accounts by Ostrovsky and by Gordon Thomas and Martin Dillon; they are not independently authenticated directives, legal findings or a verified description of present operations.234
Overview
In By Way of Deception, Victor Ostrovsky describes kidon, translated as “bayonet,” as a unit within Komemiute, formerly Metsada.5 His 1990 book already uses the name Komemiute; the organizational description and execution-list account are historical claims in that book.678
Ostrovsky writes that he was approached in 1979 and turned the job down because it would keep him away from his family, and that he learned only after joining the Mossad that he had been groomed for kidon.9 He re-entered the process in October 1982.10
Execution-List Process
Ostrovsky describes the following sequence for the formal execution list, which he distinguishes from “operational emergency” killings decided by the head of the Mossad:11
- Request: the head of the Mossad asks the Prime Minister’s Office to place a name on the list12
- PM referral: the prime minister sends it to a special judicial committee13
- Secret judicial committee: a committee whose existence is unknown to the Israeli Supreme Court; it sits as a military court and is composed of intelligence, military, and justice officials; hearings are held at various locations, often a private residence; membership and location change for each case14
- Trial in absentia: Two lawyers assigned — prosecution and defense; accused is unaware of any proceedings15
- Verdict: Guilty → order to bring to Israel for trial, or execute at first opportunity16
- PM signature: the execution order requires the prime minister’s signature; some sign in advance, others first consider whether the hit would create political difficulties at the time17
Ostrovsky writes that the list varies from one or two names to about 100, depending on the extent of anti-Israeli terrorist activity.18
Ostrovsky describes reviewing the execution list as one of a new Israeli prime minister’s first duties.19
Operation Sphinx Example
In the Osirak prologue of By Way of Deception, Ostrovsky attributes two 1980 killings in Paris to Mossad.20 This is the memoir’s allegation, without a contemporaneous police or judicial finding here.21 Victim-identifying details, the room number and graphic mechanisms are omitted.
Meir Amit’s Assassination Rules, as Described by Gordon Thomas and Martin Dillon
Thomas and Dillon (Robert Maxwell, Israel’s Superspy) attribute to Mossad Director Meir Amit the following rules for assassination:22
- No killing of political leaders.23
- No killing of a terrorist’s family unless directly implicated.24
- Each execution requires PM sanction.25
- Framing: “Any execution is therefore not state-sponsored murder but an ultimate judicial sanction by the state.”26
Thomas and Dillon present these as rules attributed to Meir Amit.27
CIA Assassination Manual (Gottlieb, 1953)
Gordon Thomas and Martin Dillon allege that an eight-page 1953 Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) assassination manual attributed to Sidney Gottlieb was used at the Mossad academy.28 Authorship, length and transfer have not been independently verified here; the passage alone does not establish a formal doctrinal exchange.
Maxwell Case — September 1991 Kidon Meeting
Gordon Thomas and Martin Dillon allege that four men met to consider how to deal with Maxwell in September 1991.2930 Their account alleges an assassination plan,31 but supplies no authenticated meeting record here; identities are withheld because identification and necessity have not been established.
- Thomas and Dillon place the alleged first meeting at Mossad headquarters on King Saul Boulevard, Tel Aviv; participant names are withheld.32
- Thomas and Dillon place an alleged second meeting, ten days after the first, at a Pinsker Street safe house; the headquarters and safe-house meetings are separate episodes in their account.33
- Thomas and Dillon allege that Maxwell threatened to disclose intelligence activities unless he received financial help; this is their account of his motive and conduct.34
- The authors portray the alleged discussions as concerned with the damage Maxwell’s disclosures could cause; the reconstructed conversation is paraphrased and the participant’s identity withheld.35
- Thomas and Dillon frame the meetings as preparations to act against Maxwell.36 Their narrative does not independently establish an assassination decision or the cause of his death.3738
Descriptions of technical capabilities in this narrative do not establish that such means were used against Maxwell. No independently authenticated operational record is supplied here; unnecessary laboratory and weapon details are omitted.
Open Questions
- What authenticated records could establish the unit’s organization and authorization procedures over time? Ostrovsky’s 1990 book already uses Komemiute for the former Metsada department; it does not establish later changes.39
- What is the relationship between kidon operations and the U.S.-Israel intelligence relationship? Did the CIA have visibility into execution-list targets?
Related Entities
- Victor Ostrovsky — Named kidon as the unit he was originally being groomed for in 1979; provided formal execution-list process description
- Meir Amit
- Sidney Gottlieb — Thomas and Dillon attribute authorship of a 1953 CIA manual to him and say a copy was later used at the Mossad academy; authorship and transfer remain unverified in the cited passage.40
- The alleged meeting participants are not identified here; the book’s first-name attributions are not independent authentication of their identities or roles.41
- Robert Maxwell — subject of the alleged meetings in Thomas and Dillon’s narrative; the cited account does not establish an assassination finding.42
Related Concepts
- Covert Action
- Intelligence Network — Mossad organizational context; kidon within Metsada/Komemiute within the Mossad structure
Sources
- Ostrovsky, Victor, and Claire Hoy. By Way of Deception: The Making and Unmaking of a Mossad Officer. New York: St. Martin’s Press, 1990. Held electronic scan, ISBN 0-312-05613-3, with an added anonymous distributor preface (PDF p. 2); distribution date unstated. — Primary; the recruitment chapter says he was groomed for kidon after a 1979 approach; the execution-list process is described in the prologue43
- Thomas, Gordon, and Martin Dillon. Robert Maxwell, Israel’s Superspy: The Life and Murder of a Media Mogul. First Carroll & Graf edition. New York: Carroll & Graf Publishers, 2002. Held scan with extraneous distributor overlays. — Gordon Thomas and Martin Dillon, Chapter 1, PDF pp. 17–25, and Chapter 3, PDF pp. 43–44: alleged rules, manual transfer and Maxwell-related meetings; participant identities are withheld and the allegations require independent corroboration.4445