Suicide Watch Protocols

Reference. Reports what the sources say. States no conclusion of ours.

Edition label: 2026-11

Not everything on this page is footnoted. Our citation check covers the main text, but not headings, the lists of related entries and sources, or open questions, which may state facts without a footnote. Check the footnoted text or the source before relying on them.

Context: Federal Bureau of Prisons (BOP) protocols for monitoring high-risk detainees at Metropolitan Correctional Center (MCC)1
Relevance: Multiple simultaneous protocol failures directly preceded Jeffrey Epstein’s death2

Standard Protocol

The OIG report describes distinct requirements rather than one universal suicide-watch protocol: suicide watch involved direct continuous observation3; twice-hourly rounds and institutional counts were general SHU duties4; and the post-observation cellmate direction named Epstein, although an MCC New York local policy also required that inmates discharged from suicide watch be assigned a cellmate:5

Failures in Epstein Case

The following failures were all in effect on the night of August 9–10, 2019, though their onset was staggered over the preceding weeks:10

  1. Removed from suicide watch — after the unresolved July 23 incident, which officials treated as a possible suicide attempt, Epstein was stepped down from formal suicide watch11
  2. No cellmate assigned — a written July 30 Psychology Department direction required Epstein to have an appropriate cellmate after observation ended12; no replacement cellmate was assigned after his cellmate was transferred out on August 913
  3. Required SHU rounds not performed — Tova Noel and Michael Thomas failed to conduct checks14
  4. Falsified logs — OIG found that both guards falsified records to indicate checks had been made15
  5. DVR not recording — see DVR Failure (MCC Tier L Camera); the camera covering his tier was live but not recording16
  6. Institutional counts not done — the regular institutional headcount was not performed17

William Barr described this as “a perfect storm of screwups”18. On the missed checks, he said it was apparently a consistent practice; the OIG reported finding no evidence contradicting the FBI’s determination of no criminality in how Epstein died.19

Institutional Response

Barr described his response to the death as follows:20

Barr also recalled stopping new intake to MCC and believed he redirected it to Brooklyn MDC; he did not date that action.25

Guards Noel and Thomas were indicted for falsifying records26; both entered deferred prosecution agreements, and the charges were dismissed after they fulfilled the agreements27.

Sources